Comparing GPS-Based Fitness Tracker Accuracy
Fitness trackers have become indispensable tools for monitoring various physical activities. One of the key features is GPS tracking, highly effective for outdoor exercises like running or cycling. But how does GPS-based fitness tracking fare when you move indoors? This article compares the accuracy of GPS-based fitness tracking in outdoor vs. indoor settings.
here are some of the key differences between outdoor and indoor tracking on smartwatches:
- GPS: Outdoor tracking uses GPS to track your location and distance traveled. This is important for activities like running, biking, and hiking, where you need to know how far you have gone. Indoor tracking does not use GPS, so it is not as accurate for distance tracking.
- Heart rate monitoring: Heart rate monitoring can be used to track your workout intensity and calorie burn. Outdoor tracking can use GPS to track your heart rate, while indoor tracking can use an optical sensor on the wrist. Optical sensors are not as accurate as chest straps, but they are still a good option for most people.
- Floors climbed: Indoor tracking can track the number of floors you have climbed. This can be a good way to track your activity level throughout the day, even if you are not doing a formal workout.
- Gym equipment: Some smartwatches can be used to track your workouts on gym equipment. This is done by using the accelerometer and gyroscope to track your movements.
Ultimately, the best way to track your activity depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you are mostly interested in tracking your outdoor activities, then a smartwatch with GPS is a good option. If you are more interested in tracking your indoor activities, then a smartwatch with heart rate monitoring and floors climbed tracking is a good option.
If you are looking for a smartwatch that can do both outdoor and indoor tracking, then there are a few options available. Some of the popular options include:
- Garmin Forerunner 245: This smartwatch has GPS, heart rate monitoring, and floors climbed tracking. It also has a built-in music player and can be used to track your sleep.
- ADVANCED TRAINING FEATURES: Evaluates your current training status to indicate if you’re undertraining or overdoing it. Offers additional performance monitoring features, such as training load, VO2 Max, and recovery time.
- FREE ADAPTIVE TRAINING PLANS: Get free adaptive training plans from Garmin Coach, or create your own custom workouts on the Garmin Connect online fitness community.
- ADVANCED RUNNING DYNAMICS: Provides advanced running dynamics, including ground contact time balance, stride length, vertical ratio, and more (when used with Running Dynamics Pod or HRM-Run or HRM-Tri monitors (sold separately)).
- SAFETY AND TRACKING FEATURES: Includes incident detection (during select activities) which sends your real-time location to emergency contacts through your paired compatible smartphone.
- CUSTOMIZATION: Customize with free watch faces, apps, and more from the Connect IQ store.
- Polar M430: This smartwatch has GPS, heart rate monitoring, and a built-in accelerometer. It can also be used to track your sleep.
- Measures heart rate from the wrist with six LED solution
- Integrated GPS with A-GPS data predicting positions of the GPS for greater accuracy, has a built-in accelerometer for indoor activity
- Has enhanced training features, including Polar fitness test, personalised running programme and running index via bluetooth
- Water-resistant and tracks activity and sleep 24/7, comes with vibrating alerts and smart notifications making it runner friendly
- Syncs data to the Polar flow app automatically via bluetooth
- Fitbit Charge 5: This smartwatch has GPS, heart rate monitoring, and an optical sensor for sleep tracking. It also has a built-in SpO2 sensor for blood oxygen tracking.
- This Exciting Bundle/Kit Includes: Fitbit Charge 5 Advanced Fitness & Health Tracker (Black/Graphite), Small & Large Bands, PremGear 3.3ft USB Charging Cable, PremGear Wall Adapter, PremGear Screen Protectors & PremGear Quality Cleaning Cloth
- REDEFINE YOU ROUTINE – Optimize your activity and routine with Daily Readiness, a personalized score available with your included 6-month Premium membership. Daily Readiness uses insights from your exercise, sleep and Heart Rate Variability (HRV) and lets you know of you’re ready for a workout or need to prioritize recovery (requires Premium subscription
- FIND YOUR CALM – Understand how your body reacts to stress with a daily Stress Management Score and measure your body’s in-the-moment physical response with an on-wrist EDA Scan app. Plus, find your calm with expanded mindfulness tools and a detailed breakdown of your Stress management Score (included with your 6-month membership
- TRACK TRENDS IN YOUR WELLNESS – See important changes in your wellness with health metrics such as SpO2 the level of oxygen in your blood heart rate variability, breathing rate…+ See your personal range and trends for each metric from the past month
- LEVEL UP YOUR HEALTH & FITNESS – Transform your insights into impact with your included 6-month Premium membership and discover inspiration with new recommended workouts, mindfulness sessions, fun challenges and more. Also, get health insights specific to your body and mind for a more complete understanding of your well-being
- Samsung Galaxy Watch Active 2: This smartwatch has GPS, heart rate monitoring, and an accelerometer for step counting. It also has a built-in speaker and microphone for making calls and sending messages.
- Better Insights To Reach Your Fitness Goals Get More Out Of Every Mile Thanks To Built-In Pace Coaching On The Galaxy Watch Active2; Its Advanced Sensors Keep Your Pace To Help You Better Achieve Your Run Goals
- Keep Your Beat; You Can See If Your Heart Rate Is Where You Want It With Galaxy Watch Active2. Get Automatically Alerted If Your Watch Detects A High Or A Low Heart Rate. This Device And Related Software Are Not Intended For Use In The Diagnosis Of Disease Or Other Conditions, Or In The Cure, Mitigation, Treatment Or Prevention Of Disease
- Comfortably Sleek The Galaxy Watch Active2 Is Light Enough To Wear Anywhere Comfortably; It Comes In Aluminum Or Stainless Steel And With A Variety Of Faces, Bands And Finishes So It Goes With Anything. Compatible Devices – Samsung Smartphone, Non-Samsung Android Smartphone (Android Os 5.0 And Above Ram 1.5Gb And Above), Ios 9.0 And Above Iphone 5 And Above
- Level Up Your Downtime; Galaxy Watch Active2’S Built In Sleep Tracker Offers Valuable Insights On How To Get A Better Night’S Sleep. It Also Monitors Your Stress Level And Helps You Recently With The Integrated Calm App. This Device And Related Software Are Not Intended For Use In The Diagnosis Of Disease Or Other Conditions, Or In The Cure, Mitigation, Treatment Or Prevention Of Disease
When choosing a smartwatch for tracking your activity, it is important to consider the features that are important to you. Consider your budget, the activities you do, and the level of accuracy you need.
Outdoor Tracking
GPS Accuracy
Outdoor tracking using GPS is generally accurate, capturing data like distance, speed, and route with a high level of precision.
Altitude and Elevation
Many GPS-enabled trackers can also measure altitude and elevation changes, providing comprehensive data for outdoor activities like hiking.
Environmental Factors
While GPS is highly accurate outdoors, its performance can still be affected by buildings, trees, and weather conditions.
Indoor Tracking
Limited GPS Utility
GPS is less effective for tracking indoor activities, often due to signal interference from walls and ceilings.
Alternative Metrics
Indoor tracking usually relies on other sensors like accelerometers and gyroscopes to estimate metrics such as distance and pace.
Treadmill Mode
Some fitness trackers have a dedicated ‘Treadmill’ or ‘Indoor Run’ mode to compensate for the lack of GPS data.
Hybrid Solutions
Assisted GPS (A-GPS)
Some trackers use Assisted GPS, which combines GPS data with Wi-Fi and cell tower information for improved accuracy, especially during transitions from outdoor to indoor.
Indoor Positioning Systems
A few advanced fitness trackers are beginning to integrate Indoor Positioning Systems (IPS) to improve tracking in indoor spaces.
Outdoor vs. Indoor Tracking Smartwatch FAQ
Q: Can I manually correct inaccuracies in my indoor or outdoor tracking data?
A: Some fitness apps allow you to edit workout data, but it’s generally better to rely on calibrated devices for accurate metrics.
Q: Are there any fitness trackers that excel in both indoor and outdoor tracking?
A: High-end models with a range of sensors and features are more likely to provide accurate tracking in both settings.
Q: Is GPS the only option for outdoor tracking?
A: While GPS is the most accurate, other methods like pedometer-based tracking can also provide reasonable estimates for outdoor activities.
What is the difference between outdoor and indoor tracking?
Outdoor tracking uses GPS to track your location and distance traveled. Indoor tracking does not use GPS, so it is not as accurate for distance tracking. Indoor tracking can use an accelerometer and gyroscope to track your movements, but this can be less accurate than GPS.
Which is more accurate, outdoor or indoor tracking?
Outdoor tracking is typically more accurate than indoor tracking because it uses GPS. However, there are some smartwatches that use other technologies to improve the accuracy of indoor tracking.
What are the benefits of outdoor tracking?
Outdoor tracking can be a great way to track your progress over time, especially if you are training for a specific goal. It can also be a great way to explore new places and stay motivated.
What are the benefits of indoor tracking?
Indoor tracking can be a great way to track your activity level throughout the day, even if you are not doing a formal workout. It can also be a good way to track your progress if you are working out on a treadmill or other gym equipment.
What are the limitations of outdoor and indoor tracking?
Outdoor tracking can be limited by the environment, such as tall buildings or trees that can block GPS signals. Indoor tracking can also be limited by the environment, such as the presence of metal or other objects that can interfere with the signal.
How can I improve the accuracy of outdoor and indoor tracking on my smartwatch?
There are a few things you can do to improve the accuracy of outdoor and indoor tracking on your smartwatch:
* Wear the device snugly on your wrist.
* Keep the device away from metal objects.
* Make sure the device has a clear view of the sky for GPS tracking.
* Update the device's firmware.
Which smartwatch is best for outdoor and indoor tracking?
The best smartwatch for outdoor and indoor tracking depends on your individual needs and preferences. Some factors to consider include the features you need, your budget, and the activities you do.
Conclusion
Outdoor and indoor tracking have their unique challenges and advantages when it comes to accuracy. While GPS excels in outdoor settings, its utility is limited indoors, requiring the use of alternative sensors and technologies. Understanding these limitations will help you choose the right device and settings to track your fitness activities accurately, regardless of the environment.
This product presentation was made with AAWP plugin.